• Home
  • Practice Areas
    • Personal Injury
      • Motor Vehicle Accidents
        • Car Accidents
        • Motorcycle Accidents
        • Texting-While-Driving
        • Bus & Pedestrian Accidents
      • Dog Bites
      • Premises Liability
      • Wrongful Death
    • Workers’ Compensation
      • What You Need To Know About Your Workplace Injury
      • Types Of Workers’ Compensation Claims
      • Third Party Liability
      • Workplace Accidents
        • Construction Site Accidents
        • Industrial Accidents
      • Types Of Injuries
        • Head Injuries
        • Repetitive Motion Injuries
        • Pre-Existing Conditions
    • Bad Faith Insurance
    • Class Action Lawsuits
  • Firm Overview
  • Attorneys
    • Bruce Stoltze
  • Blog
  • Contact
Stoltze & Stoltze, PLC

Stoltze & Stoltze, PLC

Des Moines Employment Attorney

Free Consultations

Evening and Weekend Appointments

CALL 515-244-1473 or Email Us

  • Personal Injury · Business Litigation · Work Injury - Call 515-244-1473
You are here: Home / Personal Injury & Work Injury & Employment Law Blog / Religious Discrimination / Retailer Fails to Make Religious Accommodation in Dress Code

Retailer Fails to Make Religious Accommodation in Dress Code

Posted on June 2, 2015

The EEOC scored a victory over retailer Abercrombie & Fitch regarding a religious accommodation violation. The case involves a woman who interviewed with the retailer while donning a headscarf. The manager elected not to hire the prospective employee, not because of a then undisclosed religious affiliation, but because her attire violated A&F’s strict dress code.

So ignited a case with many twists and turns. The woman, who was indeed a practicing Muslim, along with the EEOC, sued Abercrombie in federal court for violation of Title VII and won, despite the fact the woman never expressed a desire for religious accommodation.

Later, the ruling was reversed by the 10th Circuit, who reasoned that a company’s failure to accommodate a religious practice could not violate Title VII unless the employer has actual knowledge of a person’s need for an accommodation.

However, when the Supreme Court took a look, they ruled that employers do not need to have actual knowledge of a person’s need for a religious accommodation to violate ‘Title VII’. The Civil Rights Act of 1964, or Title VII, makes discrimination on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, or national origin illegal.

The majority opinion on the perplexing case states that Title VII is not neutral regarding religion. Instead, Title VII gives religious practices “favored treatment,” placing affirmative obligations on employers to accommodate religious practices, whether known or suspected.

The EEOC and the prospective employee are victorious, for now, but Abercrombie may have one more play. In 1977, the Supreme Court established a “de minimis” rule — any accommodation causing more than a de minimis cost (impacting a business monetarily or otherwise) would be an undue hardship. Could throwing out a dress code to accommodate one employee be a considered a hardship on a business like Abercrombie? We’ll keep you posted.

If you have been a victim of employment discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, or national origin, contact the employment Law Offices of Stoltze and Updegraff PLC for help today.

Source: National Law Review, “EEOC Wins Big at Supreme Court on Religious Accommodation Case”, accessed June 1, 2015

Filed Under: Religious Discrimination Tagged With: Des Moines religious discrimination attorney, dress code discrimination, Muslim religious employment discrimination lawyer

Practice Areas

  • Personal Injury
  • Workers’ Compensation
  • Bad Faith Insurance
  • Class Action Lawsuits

Blog Categories

  • Age Discrimination (5)
  • Arbitration Agreements (1)
  • Car Accidents (53)
  • Child Custody (1)
  • Child Support (1)
  • Class Action (2)
  • Dog Bite (2)
  • Employment Law (24)
  • Family Law (1)
  • FMLA Denial & Retaliaiton (6)
  • Gender Discrimination (4)
  • Iowa Wage and Hour Law (3)
  • Marital Property Division (3)
  • Motorcycle Accidents (4)
  • Non-Compete Agreements (2)
  • Pedestrian Accidents (10)
  • Personal Injury (44)
  • Personal Injury (2)
  • Personal Injury & Work Injury & Employment Law Blog (7)
  • Personal Injury Settlement (3)
  • Premises Liability (6)
  • Product Liability (2)
  • Religious Discrimination (2)
  • Sex Discrimination (6)
  • Temporary Orders (1)
  • Third Party Injury (6)
  • Truck Accidents (11)
  • Whistle-blower Retaliation (1)
  • Work Related Stress Disorders (1)
  • Workers Compensation (68)
  • Workplace Discrimination (5)
  • Wrongful Death (18)
  • Wrongful Termination (7)

Contact Information

Stoltze & Stoltze, PLC
Personal Injury Lawyers

300 Walnut St, Suite 260
Des Moines, IA 50309

Phone: 515-244-1473
Fax: 515-244-3930

DIRECTIONS

stoltz-building

Stoltze & Stoltze America's Top 100 Attorneys Rated by Super Lawyers

The law firm of Stoltze & Stoltze, PLC, provides legal services to people in the cities of Des Moines, West Des Moines, Davenport, Ames, Waukee, Mason City, Cedar Rapids, Burlington and Fort Dodge, and Polk County, Warren County, Dallas County, Scott County, Story County, Cerro Gordo County, Linn County, Des Moines County and Webster County, Iowa.

© 2022 by Stoltze & Stoltze, PLC. All rights reserved · Disclaimer · Privacy Policy · Sitemap · Return to Top